A proposal to build a Dan Murphy’s liquor store with a childcare centre above it in Avalon has drawn widespread opposition from local residents, citing concerns about traffic, safety, and the impact on small businesses.
The development application DA2024/1091 seeks to construct a $7.2 million facility on Careel Head Road, Avalon Beach. The plan includes a Dan Murphy’s liquor store on the ground floor and a 60-place childcare centre directly above it.
The proposal also features additional retail outlets as part of the site redevelopment. Submissions about the proposal have been reviewed by NBC, with the Northern Beaches Local Planning Panel responsible for determining its future.
The project has triggered strong community resistance, with more than 130 objections lodged, including formal submissions from local residents and health authorities. Concerns range from traffic congestion and parking issues to the perceived incompatibility of placing a liquor store and childcare facility in such close proximity.
Key Issues Raised by Residents
Traffic and Parking Challenges
Residents have pointed to existing traffic congestion on Careel Head Road and Barrenjoey Road as a significant concern. The location already experiences heavy congestion, particularly during weekends and summer, with cars frequently parked in “No Stopping” zones near the proposed site. Locals worry that the addition of a major retail outlet will exacerbate these issues.
Lee de Gail, a long-time resident of Careel Head Road, noted that the intersection is already hazardous due to poor visibility and the high volume of vehicles. “This proposal will clearly exacerbate this issue, not to mention it is a dangerous intersection,” they wrote, further describing the area as unsuitable for a large-scale retail development.
Impact on Local Businesses
Opponents of the plan argue that Avalon is already well-serviced by existing bottle shops, with four liquor stores in the immediate vicinity. Kathryn Walsh, a nearby resident, expressed concern that introducing a Dan Murphy’s could lead to the closure of smaller, locally-owned businesses that have served the community for years.
Child Safety Concerns
Many submissions have criticised the decision to co-locate a childcare centre with a liquor store, describing it as inappropriate and potentially harmful. Robert Hills, a resident of Coral Close, called the combination “completely unacceptable,” adding, “Who thought it was appropriate to mix alcohol with children?” Health authorities, including the Northern Sydney Local Health District, have also formally objected, citing the Northern Beaches’ higher-than-average rates of alcohol-related harm.
Broader Implications for Avalon
Residents fear that the proposed development’s design and scale are incompatible with Avalon’s character and streetscape. Ms De Gail described the project as a “monstrosity” and an “eyesore,” arguing that it does not reflect the community’s identity. There is also concern about the impact on property values and the potential strain on existing infrastructure.
Next Steps
The Northern Beaches Local Planning Panel will review the city authority’s report on the proposal, which incorporates feedback from community submissions. The timeline for a decision remains unclear, but the high level of opposition indicates that the plan faces significant hurdles.
Residents and health organisations alike are urging the council to reject the proposal, emphasising the importance of prioritising community needs, safety, and local business sustainability.
Published 16-Jan-2025